Cards and a booklet from the What Matters Most workshop toolkit.
Case Study: What Matters Most

Mapping Community Values for Better Climate adaptation

A shared starting point for communities and governments facing hard choices.

Partners: Living Lab Northern Rivers, NSW Reconstruction Authority.

What We Did: Designed a workshop toolkit and visualisations that reframe disaster adaptation around community values—now informing the NSW Government’s first multi-hazard Disaster Adaptation Plan.

Two booklets, the first called About Me and the second calle About My Community, next to a pile of cards. The first card on the deck is labelled Post Office. The card below the deck is pink and has a yellow circle on it with a label that says 'Matters Most'
Three visualisations, each showing a collection of different sized circles with labels in them. The labels and circles are in the same position on all three visualisations and include things like Clean Air, Healthy Waterways and Public School.  The first one is titled 'As your community adapts to climate change, what matters most?'. The second is titled 'Which of these things did people say give their community its character, and the circles have lighter or darker shading. The third is titled 'Which of these things did people say the government should focus on funding in their community and these circles also have lighter or darker shading.

Adapting to climate change means making tough choices: deciding what to preserve, what to change, and what to let go of. On Bundjalung, Yaegl and Gumbaynggirr Country, where the Northern Rivers community is still recovering from the 2019–20 bushfires and the 2022 floods, those trade-offs loom large.

Without first understanding what people value, we can’t be ready for the difficult conversations and choices that must be made about how to recover and adapt. People fall back on assumptions, the loudest voices prevail, and decisions don’t gain lasting support.

Tasked with preparing a multibillion-dollar Disaster Adaptation Plan, the NSW Reconstruction Authority needed to better understand the community’s values and vulnerabilities so their perspectives could complement technical risk information. The government team knew it mattered, but weren’t sure how to gather and represent the knowledge in a way that could genuinely inform planning and investment. Parallel Lines was asked to bring clarity to this challenge.

Workshop participants in conversation around a table with cards and booklets on it.

Participants in one of the ‘What Matters Most’ workshops—this one in Lismore (Photo: Tajette O'Halloran)

Close up of a person holding cards and writing in a booklet. Some of the cards are pink and say Matters Most, Matters More and Matters Least. The other cards are white, with one label visible which says Access to the Electrical Grid. The person is writing with their right hand in a booklet, where they have listed Healthy Soil, Public Hospital, Mobile Phone Coverage, Clean Air and Access to the electrical grid.

The workshop toolkit in use. (Photo: Tajette O'Halloran)

Starting with values

Working with Living Lab Northern Rivers, we began by asking what values, vulnerability and risk really mean in this context. This showed that:

  • Risk is ultimately subjective: how much something is at risk depends on how much someone values it.

  • People aren’t inherently vulnerable—rather the actions and decisions of others make it harder for some people to protect what they value.

A big part of our role was helping the government team see how this different approach could give them what they needed. Understand values, and risk and vulnerability come into focus.

Sometimes what communities care about most isn’t what the data suggest they should worry about most.

Dan Etheridge
Engagement Director, Living Lab Northern Rivers

Giving shape to values

Values are hard to compare. A local fire station, fairness and healthy waterways all matter, but they are different kinds of thing. To make sense of this, we began by creating a Community Values Wheel that sorts values into outcomes, systems, roles, places and things.

Before designing anything participants would use, we first imagined the visualisations we wanted to share with the community and government, then shaped tools and experiences to gather the information for those visualisations.

a circular diagram with radial segments for different groups of systems, roles and things. There are also concentric rings. From inside to out, they are labelled Valued Outcomes, Valued Systems, Valued Roles and Valued Places and Things.

An example of a Community Values Wheel.

Relational Workshops

We designed a workshop toolkit that was flexible enough for everyone to speak from their own experience, and structured enough for their responses to be brought together in compelling visualisations. Participants sort a deck of values cards from ‘Matters Most’ to ‘Matters Least’, using the cards to answer questions about their community. Our aim was for people to leave with something too: a chance to focus and reflect, hear what others in their community value, deepen their understanding of adaptation, and contribute to planning in a way that feels more natural and connected to their experience.

A smiling woman sitting in conversation with a group at a workshop table. Each person is sorting cards into piles.

Workshop participants sorting values cards to decide what matters most for their community. (Photo: Tajette O'Halloran)

The Living Lab team and Golden Threads Studio ran nine workshops from Murwillumbah to Grafton, including dedicated sessions for high school students and for people experiencing homelessness. At the end of each session, the team gathered the data and, using the custom digital tool we designed with Thomas Ricciardiello, we explored the results and turned them into a collection of visualisations.

A visualisation representing responses to the question 'As your community adapts to climate change, what matters most?' In the visualisation are many circles with labels, arranged together in a large circular pattern. Smaller circles are clustered around the outside, and larger circles appear in the centre. The larger the circle, the more people said that thing 'matters most'. Some of the larger circles include Clean Air, Public Hospital, Healthy Waterways, Affordable Groceries, Affordable Rental Housing, Public School and Rural Fire Service.
Three visualisations, each showing a collection of different sized circles with labels in them. The labels and circles are in the same position on all three visualisations and include things like Clean Air, Healthy Waterways and Public School.  The first one is titled 'As your community adapts to climate change, what matters most?'. The second is titled 'Which of these things did people say give their community its character, and the circles have lighter or darker shading. The third is titled 'Which of these things did people say the government should focus on funding in their community and these circles also have lighter or darker shading.
Three circle plot visualisations
A collection of visualisations, some showing circle plots, others showing bar charts, one showing a map, another showing a table, and one with a quote.

What Emerged

Across ages, genders, towns and groups, the same things kept rising to the top: clean air, healthy waterways, public schools and hospitals. The signal was strong and consistent: across a diverse community, there was a holistic, nuanced understanding of what matters most in climate adaptation.

That picture is now informing the region’s Disaster Adaptation Plan, providing policymakers with a view of community values that is structured and comparable. Participants saw what their neighbours care about, which is where hard conversations about trade-offs begin.

Bringing values into focus doesn’t make these difficult decisions easy. But it does create space for people to come together and build the shared understanding that means they can make those decisions together.

Link Copied